DIY Gutter Guards vs. The Real Thing

DIY Gutter Guards vs. The Real Thing

Guarding your home or commercial property against the elements isn't just about roofs and walls. Your gutters are unsung heroes when it comes to maintaining the structural integrity of your property. In this guide, we’ll compare DIY and professional installation, from pros and cons to cost considerations and tips for selecting the right gutter guards.

What Are Gutter Guards?

Gutter guards provide a protective covering to your gutter system, preventing the accumulation of debris, such as leaves, twigs, and dirt, while allowing rainwater to flow freely. They play a crucial role in reducing the frequency of gutter cleaning, preventing water damage, avoiding pest infestations, and enhancing the longevity of your gutters. But the question remains: should you opt for DIY installation or call in the professionals?

Pros and Cons of DIY Gutter Guards

Installing gutter guards yourself is an option worth considering for many property owners. However, to make an informed decision, evaluating the various advantages and disadvantages is essential.

Pros of DIY Gutter Guard Installation

  • Cost-Effectiveness: A significant benefit of DIY gutter guards is their affordability. Compared to professional installation, DIY gutter guards are a more cost-friendly choice. You will have to pay for the materials but save on labor costs.
  • Variety of Choices: There are several types of gutter guards, including mesh, screen, foam, and brush guards. This array of options allows you to select the best gutter guards that meet your property’s needs based on factors like climate and common types of debris.
  • Immediate Installation: DIY gutter guards offer the flexibility of immediate installation. You can install them whenever you have free time without the need to schedule an appointment and wait for a professional.
  • DIY Satisfaction: If you are a hands-on homeowner who enjoys DIY projects, installing your gutter guards can provide a sense of accomplishment. It also gives you firsthand knowledge of your gutter system, making it easier to spot future issues.

Cons of DIY Gutter Guard Installation

ladder for gutter install
  • Time and Effort: Installing gutter guards alone can be time-consuming and physically demanding, especially for large properties. It involves climbing up and down ladders; if you're not accustomed to such tasks, it can prove tiring and even hazardous.
  • Potential for Mistakes: Gutter guard installation may seem straightforward, but there's room for error. Improper installation can lead to issues like pooling water or even damage to your gutters. These issues may negate any initial savings from avoiding professional installation.
  • Durability Concerns: While there are high-quality DIY gutter guard options, professionally installed ones may be more durable. Less durable materials might not withstand harsh weather conditions, leading to potential damage or the need for more frequent replacements.
  • Lack of Warranty: Most DIY gutter guards don’t come with a warranty, leaving you without coverage if the guards fail or cause damage to your gutters. In contrast, many professional installations include a warranty as part of the service.
  • Safety Concerns: Depending on the design of your property, installing gutter guards can involve working at dangerous heights. If you aren't comfortable with this or don't have the necessary safety equipment, there is a risk of injury.

Pros and Cons of Professional Gutter Guards

Opting for professional installation of your gutter guards presents an attractive option for many homeowners and commercial property owners. However, like all decisions, it has unique pros and cons.

Pros of Professional Gutter Guards

  • Expert Installation: With professional installation, you can rest assured that the job is done with expertise. Professionals have the knowledge and experience to install gutter guards correctly, ensuring that they function optimally and help prolong the lifespan of your gutter system.
  • High-Quality Materials: Professionals often use higher-grade materials for gutter guard installation, including steel or high-grade aluminum. These materials tend to be more durable, providing enhanced protection against different weather conditions and increasing the lifespan of your gutter guards.
  • Warranties and Guarantees: Professional installations typically have a product warranty or service guarantee. These assurances provide peace of mind, knowing that you're covered in case of issues with your gutter guards.
  • Safety: Installing gutter guards can be risky, especially for multi-story properties. Professionals are trained to work at heights and have the necessary safety equipment to reduce the risk of accidents.

Cons of Professional Gutter Guards

  • Higher Costs: A notable downside of professional gutter guard installations is the cost. You're not only paying for the materials but also for the labor. The overall price can be substantially higher compared to DIY installations.
  • Scheduling: Unlike DIY installation that you can do at your convenience, professional installations require scheduling an appointment. Depending on the company's workload, you might have to wait several days or weeks for installation.
  • Less Personal Involvement: Some homeowners take pride in completing home improvement tasks. With professional installation, you gain the satisfaction of completing the job yourself.
  • Potential for Overcharging: Some unscrupulous contractors might overcharge for their services if you're unfamiliar with gutter guard materials and their costs. It's essential to get quotes from multiple service providers and do your research to ensure you're getting a fair deal.

Cost Considerations for DIY and Professional Gutter Guards

While DIY and professional gutter guard installation represent an investment in your property's upkeep, they vary significantly in their financial outlay.

DIY Costs

DIY gutter guard installations are often attractive for their cost-saving potential. The primary expense involved is the cost of the materials. Gutter guards can range from $0.50 to $6.00 per foot, depending on the type and quality of the materials. Mesh and screen guards tend to be more affordable, while more robust and durable options can be at the higher end of the price range.

Apart from the cost of the guards, you may also need to consider the cost of tools if you still need them. Basic requirements could include a sturdy ladder, safety gear (such as gloves and safety glasses), a gutter scoop for cleaning, and a power drill for securing the guards.

Professional Costs

Professional installations can be significantly more costly due to the added labor expense. The price for professionally installed gutter guards can range from $7.50 to $10 per foot, including materials and labor costs.

The exact cost can depend on several factors, including the type of gutter guard chosen, the complexity of the installation (which can be affected by the design and height of the property), and the rates charged by the professional installer. Companies may also charge additional fees for cleaning your gutters before installation or disposing of old gutter guards.

Although professional installation comes with a higher upfront cost, it could save you money in the long term. High-quality, professionally installed gutter guards will likely last longer and come with a warranty, saving on replacement costs and giving you peace of mind.

Tips for Selecting the Right Type of Gutter Guards

Choosing the right gutter guard for your property isn't a one-size-fits-all scenario. It's a decision that should be tailored to your unique circumstances, considering a range of factors. Here are some tips to guide you through the selection process:

  • Assess the Common Types of Debris: If pine trees surround your property, for example, smaller pine needles can clog mesh or screen gutter guards, making solid cover or foam gutter guards a better option. On the other hand, larger debris like leaves and twigs can be effectively handled by mesh, screen, or surface tension (also known as reverse curve) gutter guards.
  • Evaluate Your Roof Type: Certain guards, like surface tension models, work best with specific roof materials and steep slopes, directing water into the gutter while deflecting debris.
  • Understand Local Weather Conditions: If your area frequently experiences heavy rainfall or snow, select a gutter guard that can handle high water flow without clogging or collapsing under snow weight. Similarly, if you live in a windy area, choose a type that firmly attaches to the gutters to prevent them from being blown off.
  • Consider Maintenance Needs: All gutter guards will need some maintenance, but some require less. For example, foam and brush gutter guards may need more frequent cleaning as debris can get stuck in or on them, whereas screen or mesh gutter guards are easier to maintain.
  • Examine Durability: Look for gutter guards made from durable materials that can withstand your local climate conditions. While plastic gutter guards may be less expensive, they may not endure extreme temperatures as well as aluminum or steel options. The longer the guard lasts, the more cost-effective your investment.
  • Check Compatibility with Your Gutters: Not all gutter guards will fit all gutter types. Ensure your chosen product is compatible with your existing gutters to ensure a proper fit and efficient performance.
  • Review Product Ratings and Reviews: Look at the product's customer ratings and reviews to understand its performance and durability. You should also check if the product has been independently tested or certified by recognized industry organizations.

Pacific Gutter: Your Reliable Gutter Guard Solution 

If you're located in areas like Seattle, Portland, Tacoma, Vancouver, Salem, Eugene, Tukwila, Kent, Gresham, or Bellevue, Pacific Gutter is your premier choice for professional, high-quality gutter guard installation. We proudly install Gutter Shutter gutter guards, a premium product designed to effectively keep out various debris types, from leaves to pests, ensuring uninterrupted water flow even during heavy rainfall.

Made from durable aluminum, Gutter Shutter guards are guaranteed not to clog, thus saving you from dangerous manual debris removal tasks. The system includes high-grade aluminum gutters, gutter covers, and gutter downspouts that are assured never to pull away from your home. Gutter Shutter uses liquid adhesion to suck the rain water into and through the gutter system while leaves and debris roll right over the top.

Take the first step towards safeguarding your property from potential gutter-related damage by scheduling your free gutter and gutter guard estimate today. Pacific Gutter is committed to delivering top-notch gutter solutions throughout Portland, Seattle, Tacoma, and nearby areas.

The Best Choice for Your Home’s Health

Choosing the right gutter guards is an investment in your home's maintenance and long-term structural integrity. Balancing factors such as cost, installation complexity, maintenance needs, and your local climate conditions can seem daunting, but with careful consideration, you can make a decision that protects your property while fitting your budget and lifestyle. 

Whether you opt for a DIY solution or engage a professional service like Pacific Gutter, remember that the ultimate goal is a sturdy, reliable system that shields your home against water damage and preserves its value for years to come.

Recent Articles

Get a free estimate

Our team of specially trained technicians will come to your home and provide a thorough gutter assessment & solution plan custom built for you and your home's needs.